Innovation and Military Capability Gaps in European Defense

Spain participates in European defense innovation programs and has industrial activity across a range of technological fields, but that participation alone does not establish how many projects become integrated systems and available military capabilities. Opinion Paper 116/2026, Innovation Is Not Enough: The Three Valleys Between Technology and European Military Capability, examines the gaps separating technological development from its effective use by the armed forces.

The paper, prepared by Guillem Colom Piella, a doctor of international security and associate professor at the Spanish Institute for Strategic Studies, identifies three critical phases. The first covers the transition from research to a product that meets an operational need, shaped by factors including technical maturity, funding, certification, and the definition of military requirements. The second lies between a viable product and production at scale, which requires industrial capacity, available components, quality control, and predictable contracts.

The third gap concerns converting an acquisition into an effective capability. According to the analysis, a delivered and certified system may not be ready for use if trained personnel, infrastructure, maintenance, doctrine, organization, interoperability, or command structures are lacking. Procuring a platform addresses the materiel component but does not, by itself, guarantee operational availability.

Funding, Production, and Integration

The paper notes that Europe has instruments such as the European Defence Fund, European Defence Agency initiatives, and NATO innovation programs. However, these mechanisms serve different priorities and institutional frameworks, meaning they do not always link research with a buyer and an end-user unit. Colom Piella also warns of the risk that some projects may be geared toward obtaining funding and conducting demonstrations rather than being driven by a specific military need.

Integrating new technologies can also create additional requirements for the armed forces. A drone, for example, may require batteries, spectrum, applications, training, and maintenance resources. The analysis argues that these requirements must be incorporated into a coherent architecture to prevent an isolated improvement from increasing burdens across the organization without resulting in a fully usable capability.

Russia’s war in Ukraine has highlighted, according to the paper, the importance of replenishing, repairing, and adapting systems at the pace of consumption and evolving threats. In that context, NATO approved a package in July 2026 to expand industrial scale through three lines of effort: conveying a signal of Allied demand to industry, mobilizing private financing, and facilitating access to industrial facilities through the NATO Engine network.

Spanish Participation and Modernization Programs

Spain has industrial activity in naval and air platforms, electronics, space, command and control, simulation, missiles, vehicles, uncrewed systems, and digital technologies. Between 2021 and 2023, Spanish entities recorded 291 participations in European Defence Fund calls, according to an analysis by Daniel Fiott published by the Elcano Royal Institute. However, the paper emphasizes that these participation figures and industrial returns do not indicate how many initiatives have resulted in contracts, integrated systems, or operational units.

The Industrial and Technological Plan for Security and Defense, presented in April 2025, included an additional investment of €10.471 billion for that year to raise security and defense spending to 2 percent of GDP. Meanwhile, the 2026 Defense Technology and Innovation Strategy, presented by the Ministry of Defense in April, establishes priorities in artificial intelligence, uncrewed systems, electronic warfare, advanced materials, and quantum technologies, as well as measures to improve planning, contracting, evaluation, and collaboration with companies, universities, and technology centers.

Among the measures proposed by Colom Piella are assigning a responsible military user to each initiative from the outset, acquiring limited batches to test systems under realistic conditions, and comparing solutions before making larger-volume purchases. The author also proposes contracts that provide production stability without preventing the modernization of components and software, as well as indicators focused on timelines to testing, the first procurement, operational units, and production and upgrade capacity. Increased investment and modernization programs can ease funding and industrial-scale problems but, according to the analysis, do not ensure a corresponding near-term improvement in operational availability.

What do you think about this information? We invite you to leave a comment and share the article on your social media channels.

Comments must comply with ClaveDefensa’s participation rules. Failure to do so may result in removal.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Puede interesarte